I got an email over the weekend asking about the correlation if any
between gold and the AUD and to be honest I didn’t know if there was any
relationship between the two other than the long bow stories generated by
economists. So I decided to have look. Whenever you start to look at the
relationship between instruments you need to first define what you are looking
at. The email I got implied that they looked the same at present therefore this
implied some form of relationship.
At a glance both instruments at present seemed to be forming some form of
broad congestion but this raises the question as to whether this a relevant
observation since it would be possible to find hundreds of instruments that
currently displaying the same pattern. However, a simple analogy will suffice
to put this into context. If you have two cars driving side by side down a road
this does not imply that they have either come from the same place or more
importantly mean that they are heading towards the same destination.
Correlation between instruments is more nuanced than simply observing that they
look the same.
Correlation can be broken down into two parts, price correlation and
returns correlation. Price correlation looks at whether prices move together
with any degree of regularity and traders often stop their analysis here
because they assume that if they move together then the impact of either an
account or trading system will be the same. The issue with this is that it is
not representative of the full picture. There is a second arm to correlations
and this is the idea that returns between instruments can be correlated. It is
important to note that it is possible for an instruments to have very high
price correlations – in simple terms they look similar but have very different
returns correlations. It is returns that matter to an account not whether something
looks the same as something else.
When breaking down correlations I like to ask a simple question – what
does the value of $1 look like if invested into each instrument since this
takes into account their differing historical returns and unpacks any link
between these returns.
As you can see from the chart the trajectory of $1 invested into either
instrument shows at times a wildly diverging path which was exacerbated during gold’s
Bull Run from 2008 and this raises the question for traders as to which
possible returns would you like to expose your portfolio to. The issue here is
not so much whether instruments look the same and have the same set up but
rather what potential impact will trading them have upon your account. It is
also quite easy to understand the differing nature of these returns by
reference to the environment within which instruments exists.
Metals such as gold are free from Government interference – they can find
their own level. Currencies are not free from such intervention, the fate of
the AUD is intimately linked to Government policy and this ultimately puts
boundaries around where the currency can go to. For example it is impossible
for a currency pair to start its run at $0.75 and for it to be $7.50 three
months later – this sort of move is the preserve of equities.
So outside of currently looking the same my answer to the question as to
whether these two instruments share any meaningful connection for traders I
would have to say no. There will also be someone who talks about the narrative
behind the relationship between commodities and a given currency but my
response to that is that this is an irrelevancy. Traders are not interested in
stories or whether things look the same, they are or should be interested in
returns.
You can view the charts attached to the articles here: https://www.tradinggame.com.au/correlation-between-gold-and-the-aud/
Author: Chris Tate
Article reproduced with kind permission of TradingGame.com.au
This piece is ended with the 3 quotes below:
“The main message I
want traders to understand is how important the disciplined execution of a well
thought out trading plan is in today's markets.” – Andy Jordan
“When you are
overconfident, you are ripe for a major setback in the market.” – Joe Ross
“Every system begins
in drawdown”. – Chris Tate
www.tallinex.com wants you to make
money from the markets
No comments:
Post a Comment